Is college worth it?

By Steve Brawner
© 2015 by Steve Brawner Communications, Inc.

Is college worth the cost, is the current model sustainable, and how can colleges and universities more effectively meet state and student needs?

Those are questions that policymakers, along with colleges and universities, must answer in a world that can change a lot in four years.

On Monday, Clint Vogus, an Arkansas State University business instructor, and Dr. Thomas Lindsay, director of the Texas Public Policy Foundation’s Center for Higher Education, told legislators that college doesn’t provide the same value it once did. Tuition costs have increased, and so has student debt, to $1.2 trillion nationally, making it the second largest source of consumer debt after home mortgages.

How big is the student debt problem? Americans, including the many who did not graduate, owe more in student debt than they do in credit card debt. Lindsay said giving students more scholarships won’t solve the problem. In fact, it will make it worse because the more government dollars that come into the system, the more colleges and universities raise the price.

The two were testifying before the Legislative Task Force to Study the Realignment of Higher Education, one of many groups appointed by Gov. Asa Hutchinson and legislators. Those groups exist to guide policy changes, to respond to changes that are already occurring, or just to ride the wave in education, health care, highways and prisons.

Vogus and Lindsay argued that despite the rising costs, a college education isn’t worth what it used to be for students or the state. Too many degree plans don’t lead to good jobs, and too many needs in the workforce aren’t being filled. Surveys indicate that students are studying less but earning a lot more A’s, and it’s not because they’ve become smarter. We’re told that, even if the world changes, college is supposed to make students more well-rounded and teach lifelong critical thinking and reasoning skills. But a 2011 report, “Academically Adrift,” found that’s often not the case. As measured by the Collegiate Learning Assessment, 36 percent of college grads didn’t show any improvement in those areas after four years of college.

Dr. Chuck Welch, president of the Arkansas State University System, defended the value of a college education as “still the greatest investment I’ve ever made in my entire life or ever will make in my entire life.” He pointed out that college graduates as a group make much higher incomes, are less likely to be incarcerated or be dependent on food stamps, and even live longer than those whose education stopped after high school.

In that respect, the numbers are clear, but the cause and effect relationship is not. Do college graduates earn more money because they have a degree? Or is it because they’re more likely to come from wealthier, educated families? In other words, did college put them on second base, or were they born there?

Progress will come slowly in this area, but it may actually come. A consensus has developed that college is too expensive and that it’s not meeting workforce needs. Vogus proposed a 90-hour degree that could be completed in three years. His employer, Arkansas State University, recently announced a three-year plan, though it relies on summer school and doesn’t reduce the required hours. Lindsay said that Texas A&M – Commerce responded to a challenge by former Gov. Rick Perry to offer a $10,000 degree by creating one that costs not much more, in part by offering most of the first two years of classes online.

If workforce needs don’t change colleges and universities, then economics might. State dollars are flat. Bain and Company, a management consulting firm, says that 43 percent of colleges and universities nationwide spend more than they can afford. The 14-17-year-old demographic that feeds colleges and universities isn’t growing. And the word is out that a college degree is not a guaranteed route to a better job.

Meanwhile, students have other choices. For $12,000, they can learn computer coding in 12 weeks of intensive training at The Iron Yard, a chain of private schools with a location in Little Rock.

In less than three months, they’ll be qualified for a very good job. They won’t have the college experiences that are meant to make them more well-rounded. But then, they can do that on their own time, independent of taxpayers, using the money they’re making.

3 thoughts on “Is college worth it?

  1. “…more government dollars that come into the system, the more colleges and universities raise the price.”


    I went to a college when costs were much more reasonable(and a private college at that) and had no loans. I had two scholarships from excellent grades and ACT score, worked three summers in a hot oil field, and had some help from my parents. It was all quite reasonable back in the 1970s.

  2. Yes, college has become way too expensive. But to me it’s about more than getting good paying jobs. My wife and I and our two sons were able to earn degrees at highly ranked universities in different regions of the country. None of us went into high paying jobs because that wasn’t our interest, but we have done OK financially. Our sons will continue paying on their educational debts for many more years whereas my wife and I had very little debt upon graduation several decades ago.
    To me the real point of a college education is how it shapes us and what we become. We become our own person; we find our unique voice. All around me I see people with less education who have little intellectual curiosity and little ability to see beyond a very narrow horizon. Lots of these people tune into certain cable news channels, and they actually believe the things they hear! They have become puppets of political operatives who appeal to their prejudices, fear, and anger and manipulate them into doing all sorts of crazy things. What a dreadful existence! I’m sure that my remarks will cause some to see me as an elitist or a snob or worse, but I will always be grateful that college education gave me and my family the tools to think for ourselves and become our own persons. It’s hard to put a price on that.

  3. Hi, Sandy.

    I’m not sure if college is quite that anymore. I read a lot of stories about political correctness, but I don’t know if I can trust those. At the very least, it has to become more efficient. The failure rate is way too high. Can we do it in three years? Can lower the price? Have sports become too important? Should it be harder? How much of the campus culture is about broadening one’s horizons, and how much of it is about sowing one’s wild oats? What about campus sexual assaults? All of these are questions that ought to be asked.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *