Arkansas’ one star

By Steve Brawner
© 2015 by Steve Brawner Communications, Inc.

arkansasFlag Flags are symbols, and symbols mean different things to different people – good people.

For some, the Confederate flag represents regional pride, a connection to the ancestral past, and sacrifice. For others, it’s a symbol of oppression and discrimination – long ago, recent, and present. For others, it’s about vague, undefined defiance. And for a small number of people, including that mass murderer in Charleston, it’s an inspiration to do very bad things.

Three out of four of those associations aren’t positive.

You can display almost whatever symbol you want on your car, property or shirt. When it comes to public areas, the Confederate flag has its places – such as in museums and adorning the graves of Confederate soldiers.

But I can’t see a good reason to display at any state Capitol a symbol that makes a lot of people feel bad and is used by a few to promote hatred and bigotry. So I’m glad the governor of Alabama ordered the flags removed from his Capitol. I hope South Carolina legislators do the same. Moreover, I support Fort Smith Southside’s decision to change its “Rebels” nickname and stop playing “Dixie.” If I were an African-American student, I would not like those being associated with my school.

So what about that one star on Arkansas’ flag?

According to the online Encyclopedia of Arkansas, the state did not have a flag until 1913. The Pine Bluff chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution decided one was needed to fly above the Navy’s new battleship, the USS Arkansas, and initiated a statewide contest to design one. Miss Willie Hocker of Wabbaseka had the winning design.

The flag the state adopted is not just one symbol, but many. The red, white and blue colors represent the United States. The diamond represents Arkansas being the only diamond-producing state. The 25 stars arrayed in the blue diamond represent the fact that Arkansas was the 25th state admitted to the union.

The first flag included three blue stars, two above and one below the word “Arkansas,” to represent the three nations to which Arkansas belonged prior to statehood: France, Spain and the United States. In 1923, the Legislature added a fourth blue star to mark the state’s membership in the Confederacy. At first, there were two stars above the word and two below. The next year, the design was changed so that the Confederate star stands alone on top. In 1987, the Legislature passed a bill, signed by then-Gov. Bill Clinton, that reaffirmed the flag’s symbolism, including the fact that the star’s purpose is “to commemorate the Confederate States of America.”

That star, and that commemoration, has not escaped notice, especially given that Hillary Clinton is running for president and has spoken in support of South Carolina removing the Confederate flag from its Capitol.

The question is, what does it mean to “commemorate”? My online Merriam-Webster dictionary defines it several ways, including “to remind people of,” and “to remember and honor.” Google’s definition includes the word “celebrate.”

Does Arkansas’ flag remember, or does it celebrate the Confederacy? It seems to me to do more remembering – at least, it does for us today. I have no more allegiance to the Confederacy than I do to France or Spain. It’s troubling that the era is marked by the single star above Arkansas rather than one of the three below. I’d rather the top star represent the U.S.A. That could be changed with an act of the Legislature, but I don’t look for that to happen.

The meanings of symbols change over time and often according to circumstance. For example, the dollar bill can represent thrift, industry or greed, depending on how it’s used. The U.S. Capitol dome sometimes appears in political commercials to represent corruption, not democracy.

For enough Americans, the Confederate flag’s meaning has never changed. It has always represented slavery and discrimination. It’s always made some of us feel set apart and looked down upon. So it doesn’t belong amidst the halls of democracy where, ideally, everyone is supposed to be represented equally.

As for Arkansas’ flag, let it be a history lesson, and a reminder of how far the state has journeyed. At one time Arkansas was French. At another, Spanish. And at another, on the wrong side of history. It’s all worth remembering, even if it all shouldn’t be celebrated.

14 thoughts on “Arkansas’ one star

  1. I appreciate your article and the openness you have shown to discuss a subject that many will try to avoid so they aren’t labeled or blacklisted. Thanks for sharing and giving many something to have food for thought.

  2. Steve….wonderful article. Thank you for posting what others like me are thinking but cant put into words.

  3. As always, Steve, I thank you for your studied and rational approach to this sometimes emotional and explosive subject. I had a great grandfather who left college to fight for the confederacy, ended up a prisoner of war in Chicago, and then returned to college to be a physician/surgeon. I wish I could have a conversation with him about this paradoxical part of his life. We can love history without glorifying it. If everyone watched SLAVERY BY ANOTHER NAME on PBS’s website, I believe people would get a better understanding of this struggle. Again, thank you for your wisdom.

  4. Very well stated, Steve. I am forwarding this to my staunch southern mother, who is having a hard time understanding all of this. She is 87 and the world has changed a lot in her time.

  5. Well said, Steve, another great column.

    Though I realize that not everyone who chooses to wear or hang a Confederate flag has ill intent, it must be acknowledged that for a great number of US citizens it has (understandably) a very negative connotation rooted in slavery, racism and oppression. We should be sensitive to that and at the very least keep it out of, as you suggest, the halls of democracy.

  6. Adam, I think you described it perfectly. We can’t hide every symbol that offends a few people, but the Confederate flag just has too much of a history.

  7. Very thoughtful, even-handed, and fair as usual, Steve. We need a lot more voices like yours in our political discussions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *